Boundaries

How Over-Personalizing Gets in the Way of Healthy Boundaries

We talk a lot about setting boundaries, but here’s the flip side: what about when we’re the ones not respecting someone else’s boundary—even if we tell ourselves we are? It’s not always obvious. In fact, it often happens quietly, in the corners of our thoughts, in the way we stew over decisions, or in how we begin treating someone differently after they set a limit we didn’t like.

A Relatable Example

Imagine this: a friend cancels plans, telling you they’re tired and need a night to recharge. You try to be supportive and say, “Of course, no worries!” But later you scroll through Instagram and see that last week they went to brunch with another friend or hit a concert with coworkers. Suddenly, you start spiraling: Why didn’t they prioritize me? Do I not matter as much? Am I not fun enough to recharge with?

You act like you’re okay with their boundary, but inside, you’re hurt, stewing, and personalizing their choice. That’s not really respect—that’s quiet resentment disguised as understanding.

How This Shows Up in Everyday Life

This pattern doesn’t just happen with friends—it shows up everywhere:

  • Family: Your sibling declines hosting a holiday because they’re overwhelmed, and you find yourself telling everyone they’re being “selfish” instead of accepting their limit.
  • Relationships: Your partner asks for a night alone, and you interpret it as rejection, withholding affection later to make your point.
  • Friendships: You pretend you’re fine with a friend’s decision to spend time with someone else but secretly keep score.
  • Work: A colleague sets a clear boundary about workload, and instead of respecting it, you vent to others about how “unhelpful” they are.

See the pattern? When we don’t accept others’ choices at face value, we end up seeking validation for our perspective. It consumes our thoughts, shapes our behaviors, and slowly poisons the relationship dynamic.

Validating the Hard Truth

Now, let’s pause and validate something: it’s human to feel hurt, disappointed, or even offended by others’ choices. You’re allowed to have those feelings. And when patterns keep repeating, it’s valuable data about what to realistically expect from that relationship.

But here’s where things go sideways: when we pretend to be okay while secretly harboring resentment. That resentment often leaks out in subtle (or not-so-subtle) ways—pettiness, spite, withholding invitations, or passive-aggressive comments. This is where respect for boundaries starts getting blurry.

Respect Isn’t Agreement

Here’s the thing: respecting someone’s boundary doesn’t mean you’re suddenly cool with it, or that you magically stop feeling disappointed, rejected, or annoyed. Respect doesn’t erase your feelings. What it does mean is that you choose not to weaponize those feelings against the other person or hold their choice against them.  

It means acknowledging and accepting that:

  • You are not always someone else’s first priority.
  • Their decisions are about their needs, not your worth.
  • Feeling disappointed doesn’t equal being disrespected.

You can respect someone’s “no” and still feel the sting of wanting a “yes.” You can accept that they need space without denying the part of you that feels hurt or unimportant. Those two truths can exist at the same time: “I wish they had said yes because I was looking forward to it, but I understand this is what they need right now, and I can let that be okay.”

Respecting boundaries means you allow space for both truths—you validate your emotions without letting them take over and twist the story into “they don’t care about me” or “I don’t matter.”

Everyday Examples that Reflect Respect

  • In friendships: Your friend cancels plans because they’re exhausted. Instead of guilt-tripping them (“But we never hang out anymore!”), you acknowledge their choice, let yourself feel disappointed, and find another way to meet your needs and spend your evening.
  • In relationships: Your partner asks for alone time. Instead of interpreting it as rejection, you remember that needing space is part of being human, not a sign of disinterest.
  • At work: A coworker declines taking on an extra task. Respect means not bad-mouthing them for “slacking,” but accepting that they’re protecting their bandwidth.

The Reality

When we equate respect with agreement, we set ourselves up for resentment. Because the truth is, you won’t always agree. You won’t always understand. Sometimes you’ll feel slighted or let down. That’s part of being in relationships with other humans who have their own needs and limitations.

Respect kicks in when you can step back and say: “This isn’t how I would have chosen it. I’m disappointed, but this is their boundary, and I choose not to punish them for having it.”

That’s what maturity and relational respect look like. It’s not about pretending you’re unaffected—it’s about how you handle the emotions that come up when you’re not prioritized, and choosing not to make those feelings the other person’s burden.

Questions to Re-Center Yourself

The next time you feel resentment bubbling after someone sets a boundary, try asking yourself:

  • What was my expectation here, and was it ever clearly communicated?
  • Am I assuming their decision is about me—or can I see how it’s about their own needs?
  • Is this worth a conversation to clarify expectations, or is this about learning to accept and let go?
  • If this pattern continues, can I adjust my expectations of this relationship without demonizing the other person?
  • How can I cope with my feelings in healthy ways—through self-soothing, journaling, or finding support elsewhere—instead of making it their problem?

The Bigger Picture

At the heart of it, respecting boundaries means keeping the focus where it belongs: on how we process our own emotions. If we can learn to regulate disappointment, reframe rejection, and accept others’ limits without turning them into an indictment of our worth, we create healthier, more sustainable relationships.

Because when everything becomes about us, we’ll always be at odds with others’ choices. But when we allow others the right to their own boundaries—and give ourselves permission to feel our feelings without weaponizing them—we step into maturity, perspective, and deeper connection.

Processing these challenges isn’t always easy—especially if you grew up without models for healthy boundary-setting. Therapy can be a powerful space to sort through these patterns and learn new ways of relating.

Click here to schedule a session if you’re ready for support in navigating boundaries, relationships, and self-growth.

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In our work together, our first step will be to help relieve you of all the pesky “shoulds” in life that keep you stuck in unwanted cycles. We’ll do this by really digging into understanding what you value most and what’s important to you so we can help you clarify what you really need and redefine what it means to be truly “you”.

We’ll talk about what’s healthy and what’s not. We’ll talk about what works and what doesn’t, and we’ll make sure we get you on a path to start making the changes you need to feel confident in your decisions and better communicate with clarity and ease.

We want you to feel good about who you are and where you are in life -- and that’s exactly what our goal is to do.

Explore the services here.

My Services

schedule a consult

All rights reserved. | Legal 

@CENTERED_WELLNESS_THERAPY

Centered Wellness  LLC
Lauren Hurd MA | LMHC
St. Petersburg, Florida

Centered wellness